Why investors shouldn’t chase the S&P 500 or any benchmark
Stephen Tuttle

As the stock market continues to reach new highs amid a historic bull market run of more than nine years, investors are becoming much more attuned to their portfolio returns – some obsessively so.

Driven by fear of underperforming the market, many investors tend to focus their attention on stock market benchmarks such as the S&P 500 as a way to gauge their own investment performance. The problem is that these benchmarks have little to do with their own investment objectives, which should form the basis for their investment decisions.

Benchmarking Investment Returns Takes Your Eye Off the Ball

Benchmarking has its place for identifying potential investments, but when it is used as the primary measure of investment success, investors may be taking their eye off of the real target which is their own investment goals.

Dalbar Inc., which has been conducting investor behavior studies for the last 14 years, has found that making investment decisions based on short-term fund performance and benchmark comparisons exposes your portfolio to unnecessary risks and costs that are bound to eat away at your long term returns. Their research shows that investors who try to time the markets and select investments based on past returns rarely outperform the market. 1

The Media Noise Can Be Deafening

Investors who intently follow the financial media are more likely to react in sympathy with the herd when short-term events such as market crashes or fiscal cliffs consume the headlines. While this month’s investment returns or calamitous economic event may be consequential to our lives at the moment, their impact on the markets, and, therefore, our portfolio over a 20- or 30-year time frame is so minimal as to cause nothing more than a tiny blip on your long-term performance.2

Between the investment guru’s, TV pundits, social media and the folks around the water cooler, it has become a deafening world, and all that noise has very little to do with your specifics goals and objectives. The short-term gyrations of the markets are driven as much by “herd mentality” as they are by fundamentals and the two are very rarely in sync.

While gathering information and educating yourself are essential parts of the process, it should be done in the context of your clearly-defined objectives and a well-conceived long-term investment strategy. It is this that keeps investors from falling into the typical investment traps, such as chasing performance or trying to time the markets.

Stop Checking Your Portfolio Performance

Investors who scour their account statements each day, week or month, or blink at every drop in the market are more apt to want to “tweak” their portfolios or compare their investment performance with the market benchmarks. The problem is, because of its volatility, the market or any stock is just as likely to be down at the particular moment you check your account as it is to be up. When investors see negative numbers, their emotions often control their decisions.

According to a behavioral finance study,4 investors dislike losing money more than twice as much they like making money. So, investors who frequently check their portfolios tend to perceive investing to be riskier than investors who don’t. The study found that investors who check their portfolios frequently take the least risk, which leads to underperformance. Since the market or stock declines are only temporary, why put yourself in the position where you may have a destructive, emotional reaction?

Focus on What’s Important

Investors who, instead, focus on their investment performance relative to their own benchmarks established through thoughtful planning, are able to achieve more consistent and stable returns. Investor benchmarks tied to specific investment objectives are much more absolute and meaningful than a market index that has little to do with you reaching your financial goals.

For instance, if you determine that your retirement goal, set for a 20-year time horizon, requires that you earn a 7% risk-adjusted annual return on your investments, what should it matter whether the S&P 500 gains 35% one year and loses 25% the next. It’s comes down to understanding the difference between required returns – that which is needed to achieve your financial goals – and desired returns, which might equate to beating the benchmarks each year. As long as your total portfolio is on track with your required returns, as measured at regular milestones, you really don’t need to distract yourself with the daily, monthly, or even annual minutia of the markets.

You need a strategy based on your investment objectives, preferences, priorities and risk tolerance because they are the only benchmarks that matter.

You Need a Plan

The investment mistake many people make is to invest without a well-conceived financial plan and a sound investment strategy to achieve it. Their investment decisions tend to be market-driven or risk- driven as opposed to goals-driven, and that typically results in knee-jerk reactions and second-guessing, which is not conducive to consistent, long-term performance.

The Dalbar studies clearly show that investors who adhere to a plan with clearly defined objectives and a tailored investment strategy managed with patience and discipline outperform those who don’t. A well-conceived investment strategy helps investors avoid costly behavioral mistakes.3

  • Having a plan enables you to stay focused on your individual benchmarks, rather than market benchmarks or indexes, which are meaningless to your long-term strategy.
  • A plan keeps you firmly grounded in risk management principles that closely track your personal risk profile while optimizing your asset allocation.
  • More importantly, strict adherence to a plan shields you from the irrational behavior of the herd which is often driven by euphoria or panic.

Benchmarks don’t fund your investment goals. Only an investment strategy can do that. Without an investment strategy based in sound principles and practices, many investors will more often than not succumb to the emotions of greed or fear which causes them to act in ways that are counter to their long term objectives. It must start with clearly defined goals and targeted objective with a specific time horizon, so you can determine how much you need to invest, the required rate of return needed to achieve your objective, and how much risk you will need to assume to achieve that rate of return.

Finally, invest for your own purposes and keep your eye on your target. That is the only benchmark that really matters.

Notes

1,2,4 Dalbar Inc. Quantitative Analysis of Investor Behavior 2018 QAIB Report. For period ending December 31, 2017.

https://2wmko64dug4x3dv4oh97ijl9-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/2018-QAIB-Report_FINAL.pdf

3PsyBlog. Nobel Prize-Winning Research on Risky Decision Making. March 2007

https://www.spring.org.uk/2007/03/nobel-prize-winning-research-on-risky.php

About Signet Financial Management

Signet Financial Management is a wealth management firm that takes a personal approach in helping high-net worth families, individuals, and business owners navigate the complexities of managing money. We believe in your financial well-being, and custom tailor solutions using sophisticated investment management tools to help you keep more of what you earn and to reach your financial goals.

Unlike many firms, Signet manages portfolios using in-house research and portfolio management. Because we rarely use outside managers, we can manage your money at a lower cost to you. This can translate into higher returns over time.

Founded in 1988, we manage approximately $800 million in assets with offices in Parsippany, NJ; Reston, VA; Chapel Hill, NC; Ft. Lauderdale, FL; and Naples Fl.

For more information, please contact Stephen Tuttle at 800-390-2755 or stuttle@signetfm.com.

You might also like
June 23, 2022
To help you focus on the most important decisions, you’ll want to prepare a realistic retirement plan that can guide you to a financially secure retirement.
Read more
June 21, 2022
Rules controlling what you can do with your 401(k) after retirement are very complicated. Consult your financial advisor before making any final decisions.
Read more
June 16, 2022
Here’s how much Americans’ borrowing costs have increased already and how to prepare for the next rate hike.
Read more
June 14, 2022
Steep downturns of stocks by 20 percent or more are relatively rare, but how long they last could portend damage — for you and the economy.
Read more
June 7, 2022
A recession can impair your personal finances. Being prepared and taking a few simple steps to reduce your risks can help you weather the economic storm.
Read more
June 2, 2022
Now may be a good opportunity to make small changes to a portfolio — and to remind oneself of the value of sound financial planning.
Read more
May 24, 2022
The S&P 500 is more than 20% below its record, putting the index on track to close in a bear market for the first time in more than two years.
Read more
May 17, 2022
In this context, a fiduciary is a financial advisor that puts your interests first — and that could make all the difference.
Read more
May 12, 2022
What if I delay retirement by one year? There are many ways retiring either sooner or later than planned can impact your life, beyond retirement income.
Read more
May 10, 2022
Now may be an opportune moment to make tactical portfolio changes — and above all to remind oneself about the value of sound financial planning.
Read more
May 5, 2022
The Fed just raised interest rates by the most in 22 years. Consumers should be mindful of the risks associated with tighter monetary policy.
Read more
April 28, 2022
Healthcare, housing, travel, supporting adult children – all of these expenses and more are subject to inflation. Here is how to plan for inflation when thinking about retirement.
Read more
April 26, 2022
Government savings bonds offer a guaranteed return, but the rules can get complicated. Here're the rules and strategies for making the most of them.
Read more
April 21, 2022
In some U.S. cities, renting is more costly than home buying. Meanwhile in tech hubs, renting remains cheaper.
Read more
April 19, 2022
Americans are entering a period when consumer prices will continue to rise steadily, which will bring a whole different set of costs and benefits to a new generation.
Read more
April 14, 2022
Carefully planning the financial aspects of your vacation and coming up with a smart approach to saving for it can relieve a lot of the pressure that vacation planning can bring.
Read more
April 12, 2022
Getting the right coverage is a challenge because there can be so many variables. Laddering life insurance is a way to tackle life insurance needs that change over time.
Read more
Tax Day 2022 April 18
April 7, 2022
Tax Day looks a little different in 2022. Here’s everything you want to know to minimize mistakes, maximize your refund and file your tax return successfully.
Read more
US shorter-duration bonds can provide attractive income
April 5, 2022
The Signet investment team thinks the hawkish pricing in short-term rates might be overdone and prefers short-maturity bonds over long-term ones.
Read more
March 31, 2022
If the billionaire tax passes it would be the biggest tax hike on record. Here’s a look at major tax changes in the budget proposal.
Read more
March 29, 2022
With just weeks to go until the tax deadline, should you be waiting to file your taxes? Are you hoping the deadline will be extended once again this year?
Read more
March 25, 2022
Financial planning goes beyond growing savings and cutting expenses. Here're 5 steps to a solid financial plan.
Read more
March 24, 2022
For women business owners, the toll of divorce can be particularly overwhelming. You might face the possibility of having to split your company with your ex-spouse.
Read more
March 22, 2022
Once a year, tidy things up to ensure you're on track for your financial goals. Follow these steps to Marie Kondo your way to a joyful financial life.
Read more
March 17, 2022
The Fed raised its short-term benchmark rate, which can affect how much you pay on your mortgage, credit cards and more.
Read more
March 15, 2022
This Equal Pay Day, the data shows the wage gap closed by 1 cent. On the surface, this looks like progress. Yet these numbers are not telling the whole story.
Read more
March 10, 2022
Electric vehicles are growing in popularity, but can be hard to find. What to know before you buy.
Read more
March 8, 2022
Factors affecting cars, rent, energy and other categories play crucial roles in determining if a drop in inflation will occur. Cross your fingers.
Read more
March 3, 2022
Learn how to get a firm grasp on your own personal rate of inflation, and employ strategies that will protect your bottom line.
Read more
February 24, 2022
When you seek to maximize the probability of outliving your savings, you risk subjecting yourself to unnecessarily low standards of living.
Read more
February 22, 2022
Some taxpayers with children didn't know that the tax credit money they were advanced last year would be deducted from their 2021 returns filed this year.
Read more
February 17, 2022
If you have parents on Medicare, here are some tips to help ensure premiums are paid so they — and you — don’t face crushing problems.
Read more
February 15, 2022
The Internal Revenue Service has a long history of raising taxpayer ire, but this tax filing season could be one for the record books. Here are 4 tips from Barron's.
Read more
February 10, 2022
Who is feeling the price squeeze the most? Here is a demographic breakdown of inflation’s impacts.
Read more
February 8, 2022
There are a lot of expenses that, although they are common and, in some cases, annual, we don’t think to plan for. Here are a few you should work into your budget.
Read more
February 3, 2022
Does this mark the rebirth of what was a dying strategy? Or was this just another spasm, already fading as technology stocks rebound?
Read more
January 25, 2022
Strong markets have swelled account balances, but changing conditions make it a good time to revisit your plan. How to get built-in inflation protection?
Read more
a person filling out a car loan application form
January 20, 2022
Auto loans are reaching the longest term and highest balance ever. Should you refinance? It really depends on what you stand to gain by refinancing.
Read more
Chart: Consumer Price Index 2018–2023
January 18, 2022
Things are about to get worse — but after that, they should steadily get better. That’s roughly how economists envisage the path of U.S. inflation in the year ahead.
Read more
January 11, 2022
The SECURE Act 2.0, autoenrollment expansion, and a continuing question: just how are retirees doing, anyway?
Read more
January 6, 2022
During the early stage of our careers, it can be challenging to prioritize retirement savings. If you haven't managed it yet, you can still get starting saving later in life.
Read more
January 4, 2022
Surprise medical bills have become increasingly common and stressful. Now, thanks to the No Surprises Act, surprise medical bills may be a thing of the past.
Read more
December 30, 2021
The New Year is the perfect time to set smart financial planning goals. Here are the top ten tips for how to step forth with a good financial audit in 2022.
Read more
December 23, 2021
In case paper documents are filling up your drawers, you may be wondering which documents you need to keep and what you can shred or otherwise dispose of.
Read more
December 16, 2021
Over time, making little changes to your finances can add up. The earlier you take these steps, the longer they have to work and the greater your outcomes will be.
Read more
December 9, 2021
A good financial planner should be able to help you answer various Social Security questions and find the right time for you to claim Social Security benefits.
Read more
December 6, 2021
As the year comes to an end, it's important to start planning your 2021 taxes to reduce your obligations wherever possible.
Read more
November 23, 2021
While the maximum Roth IRA contribution remains $6K (with a $1K catch-up contribution for those 50 and older), the phase-out ranges for eligibility to contribute have changed.
Read more
November 1, 2021
Inflation worries grow as the economy reopens. Steve Tuttle explains how to position your portfolio for financial success regardless of how much prices rise.
Read more
October 25, 2021
Amid the market volatility fear and greed can get the best of investors. These tips help control your emotions and achieve long-term success in the markets.
Read more
September 21, 2021
Financial security in retirement takes planning, commitment, and money. These 4 questions help identify your goals and needs within a retirement strategy.
Read more
July 27, 2021
There are many successful investment strategies that have performed well over time. Yet, capturing these returns is not easy for investors. Patience can help.
Read more
Dividends chart
July 6, 2021
Do you want to invest for retirement? Dividend-paying stocks can help preserve your capital over long term and generate income regardless of market conditions.
Read more
Impact of tax hikes on the stock market
April 28, 2021
Tax policy impacts corporate earnings and the stock market. However, over the long haul, other factors have more influence on the stock market performance.
Read more
March 23, 2021
Every correction seems like the start of a downturn. Yet market corrections don't lead to lengthy bear markets. Read how Signet handles market volatility.
Read more
March 9, 2021
Real assets can hedge against inflation in the current environment. Find out what two types of real assets Signet advisors focus on for a balanced portfolio.
Read more
February 1, 2021
The GameStop and AMC Entertainment story has dominated headlines recently. Steve Tuttle on why this won't have a big, lasting impact for long-term investors.
Read more
Investment lessons from 2020
January 14, 2021
2020 was a year of major upheaval. Here’re universal and timeless investment guidelines from Signet advisors to help you improve your financial situation.
Read more
8 ways to help lower your taxes
December 9, 2020
It’s a tough year for tax planning without knowing for sure which party will control the Senate. However here's how Signet advisors help clients save taxes.
Read more
November 1, 2020
Some investors think putting their money with multiple financial advisors means better results. This is not necessarily the case. It can make things worse.
Read more
October 8, 2020
In a joint study with Duke University’s Fuqua School of Business, Signet investigates how patent disclosure impacts stock price of the focal patent company.
Read more
October 1, 2020
President Obama and President Trump pursued different policies while in office. Yet results in the financial markets were awfully similar during their terms.
Read more
September 1, 2020
Sector investing is an underrated strategy for investors, while it complements a core portfolio by seeking to enhance returns or diversifying portfolio risks.
Read more
July 1, 2020
Careful asset placement helps save on taxes. Asset location seeks to identify the right type of investment to own in retirement plans vs. taxable accounts.
Read more
June 1, 2020
No single factor works all the time. Steve Tuttle highlights the performance of factor investing and shows why portfolio diversification is so important.
Read more
May 1, 2020
As Signet carefully monitors risks, we deem tax-exempt municipal bonds are generating tremendous interest from investors. See the analysis for our optimism.
Read more
April 1, 2020
COVID pandemic short-term dynamics are rapidly changing causing many unknowns. Signet explains what to focus on to improve financial standings post crisis.
Read more
February 26, 2020
Steve Tuttle comments on market volatility and what to do if you are worried. Hint: don’t let coronavirus fears rattle your investment plan.
Read more
January 1, 2020
The new law expands opportunities to save for retirement, but changes the way beneficiaries receive money from inherited IRAS. Steve Tuttle gives highlights.
Read more
December 1, 2019
The end of the year is viewed as a time of spending. It can also be a time to consider tax-saving strategies. Here're the Signet advisors' tips for retirees.
Read more
October 1, 2019
The media flurry around the elections received a boost from impeachment talk. How will the complexities that follow major political events impact markets?
Read more
August 1, 2019
The S&P 500 is again near all-time highs. Psychologically, it can be tough for some investors to stay invested and buy. However, it is not a signal to sell.
Read more
July 1, 2019
Investing during retirement can be a daunting task. Steve Tuttle explains how to build a sound retirement plan that will increase your chances of success.
Read more
June 4, 2019
Short-term bond strategies are attractive for investors seeking to enhance yield while defending against volatile markets. Here's more about their benefits.
Read more
April 1, 2019
Steve Tuttle discusses strategies on how to deal with higher federal tax liability from newly imposed limits on deductions for state and local taxes.
Read more
March 4, 2019
The emotional toll from the stock market crash of 2008 still lingers for retirees. To avoid a similar calamity may of them reduce exposure to equities.
Read more
February 1, 2019
Due to lower income tax rates the benefits to establishing Roth accounts are increasing. Here're strategies to optimize the use of tax-advantaged accounts.
Read more
July 3, 2018
Yield curve causes anxiety with some investors. Fixed income CIO, Steve Tuttle, discusses bond yields and where Signet sees income opportunities heading.
Read more
April 3, 2018
Today’s backdrop requires a fresh approach to bond investing. Here are the strategies that can reduce equity risk while providing liquidity and income.
Read more
January 3, 2018
Steve Tuttle shows why investors shouldn't bet against bonds. As stock and other risk assets rise in value, bonds are an important diversifying asset class.
Read more
December 15, 2017
Our healthcare system is complex and difficult to navigate. Signet Financial Management provides a summary of the healthcare programs available to retirees.
Read more
December 1, 2017
Even in a rising rate environment, bond ladders can mitigate downside equity risk and diversify portfolios through good and bad market cycles.
Read more