Why investors shouldn’t chase the S&P 500 or any benchmark
Stephen Tuttle

As the stock market continues to reach new highs amid a historic bull market run of more than nine years, investors are becoming much more attuned to their portfolio returns – some obsessively so.

Driven by fear of underperforming the market, many investors tend to focus their attention on stock market benchmarks such as the S&P 500 as a way to gauge their own investment performance. The problem is that these benchmarks have little to do with their own investment objectives, which should form the basis for their investment decisions.

Benchmarking Investment Returns Takes Your Eye Off the Ball

Benchmarking has its place for identifying potential investments, but when it is used as the primary measure of investment success, investors may be taking their eye off of the real target which is their own investment goals.

Dalbar Inc., which has been conducting investor behavior studies for the last 14 years, has found that making investment decisions based on short-term fund performance and benchmark comparisons exposes your portfolio to unnecessary risks and costs that are bound to eat away at your long term returns. Their research shows that investors who try to time the markets and select investments based on past returns rarely outperform the market. 1

The Media Noise Can Be Deafening

Investors who intently follow the financial media are more likely to react in sympathy with the herd when short-term events such as market crashes or fiscal cliffs consume the headlines. While this month’s investment returns or calamitous economic event may be consequential to our lives at the moment, their impact on the markets, and, therefore, our portfolio over a 20- or 30-year time frame is so minimal as to cause nothing more than a tiny blip on your long-term performance.2

Between the investment guru’s, TV pundits, social media and the folks around the water cooler, it has become a deafening world, and all that noise has very little to do with your specifics goals and objectives. The short-term gyrations of the markets are driven as much by “herd mentality” as they are by fundamentals and the two are very rarely in sync.

While gathering information and educating yourself are essential parts of the process, it should be done in the context of your clearly-defined objectives and a well-conceived long-term investment strategy. It is this that keeps investors from falling into the typical investment traps, such as chasing performance or trying to time the markets.

Stop Checking Your Portfolio Performance

Investors who scour their account statements each day, week or month, or blink at every drop in the market are more apt to want to “tweak” their portfolios or compare their investment performance with the market benchmarks. The problem is, because of its volatility, the market or any stock is just as likely to be down at the particular moment you check your account as it is to be up. When investors see negative numbers, their emotions often control their decisions.

According to a behavioral finance study,4 investors dislike losing money more than twice as much they like making money. So, investors who frequently check their portfolios tend to perceive investing to be riskier than investors who don’t. The study found that investors who check their portfolios frequently take the least risk, which leads to underperformance. Since the market or stock declines are only temporary, why put yourself in the position where you may have a destructive, emotional reaction?

Focus on What’s Important

Investors who, instead, focus on their investment performance relative to their own benchmarks established through thoughtful planning, are able to achieve more consistent and stable returns. Investor benchmarks tied to specific investment objectives are much more absolute and meaningful than a market index that has little to do with you reaching your financial goals.

For instance, if you determine that your retirement goal, set for a 20-year time horizon, requires that you earn a 7% risk-adjusted annual return on your investments, what should it matter whether the S&P 500 gains 35% one year and loses 25% the next. It’s comes down to understanding the difference between required returns – that which is needed to achieve your financial goals – and desired returns, which might equate to beating the benchmarks each year. As long as your total portfolio is on track with your required returns, as measured at regular milestones, you really don’t need to distract yourself with the daily, monthly, or even annual minutia of the markets.

You need a strategy based on your investment objectives, preferences, priorities and risk tolerance because they are the only benchmarks that matter.

You Need a Plan

The investment mistake many people make is to invest without a well-conceived financial plan and a sound investment strategy to achieve it. Their investment decisions tend to be market-driven or risk- driven as opposed to goals-driven, and that typically results in knee-jerk reactions and second-guessing, which is not conducive to consistent, long-term performance.

The Dalbar studies clearly show that investors who adhere to a plan with clearly defined objectives and a tailored investment strategy managed with patience and discipline outperform those who don’t. A well-conceived investment strategy helps investors avoid costly behavioral mistakes.3

  • Having a plan enables you to stay focused on your individual benchmarks, rather than market benchmarks or indexes, which are meaningless to your long-term strategy.
  • A plan keeps you firmly grounded in risk management principles that closely track your personal risk profile while optimizing your asset allocation.
  • More importantly, strict adherence to a plan shields you from the irrational behavior of the herd which is often driven by euphoria or panic.

Benchmarks don’t fund your investment goals. Only an investment strategy can do that. Without an investment strategy based in sound principles and practices, many investors will more often than not succumb to the emotions of greed or fear which causes them to act in ways that are counter to their long term objectives. It must start with clearly defined goals and targeted objective with a specific time horizon, so you can determine how much you need to invest, the required rate of return needed to achieve your objective, and how much risk you will need to assume to achieve that rate of return.

Finally, invest for your own purposes and keep your eye on your target. That is the only benchmark that really matters.

Notes

1,2,4 Dalbar Inc. Quantitative Analysis of Investor Behavior 2018 QAIB Report. For period ending December 31, 2017.

https://2wmko64dug4x3dv4oh97ijl9-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/2018-QAIB-Report_FINAL.pdf

3PsyBlog. Nobel Prize-Winning Research on Risky Decision Making. March 2007

https://www.spring.org.uk/2007/03/nobel-prize-winning-research-on-risky.php

About Signet Financial Management

Signet Financial Management is a wealth management firm that takes a personal approach in helping high-net worth families, individuals, and business owners navigate the complexities of managing money. We believe in your financial well-being, and custom tailor solutions using sophisticated investment management tools to help you keep more of what you earn and to reach your financial goals.

Unlike many firms, Signet manages portfolios using in-house research and portfolio management. Because we rarely use outside managers, we can manage your money at a lower cost to you. This can translate into higher returns over time.

Founded in 1988, we manage approximately $800 million in assets with offices in Parsippany, NJ; Reston, VA; Chapel Hill, NC; Ft. Lauderdale, FL; and Naples Fl.

For more information, please contact Stephen Tuttle at 800-390-2755 or stuttle@signetfm.com.

You might also like
September 28, 2023
A sound, long-term financial plan is the best way to protect your finances from stagflation. Learn how to adjust your investment strategy during economic uncertainty.
Read more
September 26, 2023
Discover the 2026 changes to 401(k) catch-up contributions under the SECURE 2.0 Act. How will it affect your taxes and retirement savings?
Read more
September 21, 2023
Curious about the cost of retiring in the US? Explore the factors that affect retirement costs and find out the top states for retirement based on the Investopedia Retirement Index...
Read more
September 19, 2023
Don't let the fear of a recession drive you to make hasty financial decisions. Check out some common mistakes people make before recessions that can hurt their finances.
Read more
September 12, 2023
Credit cards can be a financial lifeline, but they can also lead to disaster if not managed wisely. Learn to avoid overspending, high interest, and credit score damage.
Read more
September 7, 2023
Are you in a dual-career couple with an age gap? Explore retirement planning tips, including Social Security, healthcare, and financial strategies, to secure your financial future.
Read more
August 31, 2023
Learn how open communication can prevent loss of assets and familial trust, ensuring a smooth transition for the next generation.
Read more
August 29, 2023
Learn how women's investment strategies differ. Explore key research findings on gender and investment decisions.
Read more
August 24, 2023
Preparing for divorce? Learn effective strategies to protect your personal credit . Discover how to close joint accounts, freeze credit, and monitor your score.
Read more
August 22, 2023
Childhood money lessons don't always stick, but here's how parents can introduce kids to saving and compound interest.
Read more
Market volatility bulls vs. bears
August 17, 2023
Inflation is still around, a possible recession, rising interest rates and geopolitical tensions are all reasons you should think about protecting your portfolio.
Read more
A man passing a jar with coins over to his son as an illustration of inheritance
August 15, 2023
Inheriting money or assets? Discover how to invest your inheritance wisely. Learn about cash, retirement accounts, investments, properties, and businesses.
Read more
An retiree playing with his grandson
August 11, 2023
Want to support your grandkids without sacrificing retirement savings? Learn 8 smart ways, from 529 plans to trusts.
Read more
investing in dividend stocks
August 1, 2023
Learn about Signet's approach to investing in dividend stocks. Discover a better way to build a diversified portfolio for steady income!
Read more
A person using a bank's ATM
July 27, 2023
Avoid unnecessary bank fees! Learn how to steer clear of account maintenance, ATM, overdraft, and other charges. Save money with savvy banking.
Read more
Dealing with taxes
July 25, 2023
Dealing with IRS tax debt? Discover your options — setting up an IRS payment plan or using a personal loan. Compare pros and cons to make an informed decision.
Read more
July 20, 2023
Discover the key divorce mistakes to avoid for a smoother post-settlement journey. Learn how to navigate lifestyle, tax, home, legal, and insurance challenges wisely.
Read more
July 18, 2023
Explore the growing trend of semi-retirement. Learn about tax implications and other considerations to make informed decisions about your retirement plan.
Read more
July 13, 2023
Discover crucial financial tips for young adults to build a healthy future. Learn about budgeting, saving for retirement, taxes, and more.
Read more
July 11, 2023
Discover how understanding investor psychology and market patterns can lead to superior investment returns. Learn the key lessons for taking the temperature of markets.
Read more
June 29, 2023
Discover how to achieve financial freedom and overcome the struggles of limited financial security. Celebrate independence by taking steps towards a brighter financial future.
Read more
Multiple piggy banks as an illustration of having too much cash
June 27, 2023
Tim Denning, ex-banker, shares tips on changing poor money mindset that may keep you stuck. Here are a few money habits keeping you poor.
Read more
June 22, 2023
Consider the cost and hassle of maintaining a second home from afar plus your desire to travel to other destinations before buying a vacation home.
Read more
June 20, 2023
Uncover the factors influencing perceptions of wealth in America. Check out the survey findings that reveal what it truly means to feel rich.
Read more
June 15, 2023
Whether a locked or changing rate is better depends on where the Fed rate is headed. Uncover the pros and cons of each and make informed decisions.
Read more
June 13, 2023
Summer is an ideal time to reassess your financial goals and make necessary adjustments to stay on track. Explore 9 financial steps for your mid-year financial checkup.
Read more
June 8, 2023
A regret-free retirement requires several years of planning, budgeting, putting money aside, and staying the course.
Read more
A man and a woman discussing things to do before retirement
June 1, 2023
While every retirement is unique, these are some observations about what retirement issues should be prioritized and what can be delayed.
Read more
What is a good 401(k) match
May 30, 2023
Discover the ins and outs of 401(k) plans and employer matches. Learn about contribution limits, investment options, and how to maximize your retirement savings.
Read more
May 25, 2023
The US debt ceiling battle is heating up, and it could have serious implications for your finances. Stay informed to navigate uncertain times with confidence.
Read more
hold cash or invest
May 23, 2023
Should you hold cash or invest in the market? Attractive yields on savings and cash-like investments can make it tempting to hold cash instead of investing extra money.
Read more
A protester demonstrates in support for Social Security
May 18, 2023
Pay attention to these changes brought about by the Secure Act 2.0 because they could have a profound effect on your retirement plans.
Read more
7 Social Security changes for 2023
May 16, 2023
The US SSA made some important changes that could impact your retirement plan. Learn about the 8.7% increase in Social Security benefits, higher income thresholds, and more!
Read more
A woman working on her budget
May 11, 2023
Here's how to fix your budget if you want to be great with money, stop stressing about finances, and be able to claim financial freedom some day.
Read more
A rich American reading a book with his daughters on a bench in front os their detached house
May 9, 2023
QPRTs are a fairly simple way for the rich to save on taxes and keep homes in the family. However, there are a few strings attached.
Read more
Woman at the ATM checking her balance after her bank fails
May 4, 2023
Learn more about why banks fail, how FDIC insurance works to help you recoup your money, and how to protect your finances.
Read more
Managing multiple financial decisions can lead to fatigue
April 27, 2023
You’re not bad at money management. You need a better decision-making process that won’t leave you feeling exhausted and overwhelmed.
Read more
April 25, 2023
There are quite a few recurring myths that could be hurting your ability to plan properly for retirement. Here are 10 heard most often.
Read more
April 20, 2023
Will inflation subside to ultra-low pre-Covid levels or will it be a lasting problem, as in the 1970s and early 1980s? What will happen to interest rates?
Read more
April 18, 2023
With tax season in the rearview mirror, it’s a great time to give your finances a once-over. Start with these steps.
Read more
April 13, 2023
The key to retiring with no savings is to be resourceful and creative. Here are some ideas to consider.
Read more
business owners discussing a succession plan
April 11, 2023
A recent study showed that 58% of business owners lacked a succession plan. Consider these key elements to get yours on the right track.
Read more
April 6, 2023
It's important to understand how marriage affects your taxes. Avoid any potential surprises with these essential tips for filing taxes as a newlywed.
Read more
Stormy clouds over the coast
March 30, 2023
In 2022 philanthropy became a sustaining force for nonprofits despite economic pressures. Here are five lessons from last year that can shape individual giving in 2023.
Read more
IRS tax form 1040
March 28, 2023
Many audits are triggered by actions taxpayers themselves have taken. Here's a list of red flags that can cause your tax return to be targeted by the IRS for review.
Read more
Top 10 list
March 23, 2023
During the estate administration process, it is easy to see where the decedent veered off course. Often the fix was inexpensive and could have saved their heirs in legal fees.
Read more
Silicon Valley Bank logo in red background
March 21, 2023
The collapse of three US regional banks and the Credit Suisse selloff are drawing comparisons to the great financial crisis of 2008. We believe 2023 is different. Here's why.
Read more
March 16, 2023
The FDIC and other entities will protect most people’s bank and brokerage balances. But having a few backup plans is just good financial hygiene.
Read more
Warren Buffett's photo
March 14, 2023
Silicon Valley Bank's collapse highlights the dangers of being overly exposed to high-risk sectors. Investors can learn from Buffett and Lynch in such events.
Read more
March 9, 2023
Most business owners will not receive a refund from the IRS. Apply these 3 tips to help minimize what you owe at tax time.
Read more
March 2, 2023
Short-term volatility should always be expected, but long-term investors have several reasons to be optimistic about the market outlook.
Read more
February 28, 2023
The rules for inherited IRAs are complex. Understanding those rules is crucial to getting the most out of the inherited IRA — and avoiding running afoul of the IRS.
Read more
February 23, 2023
Choosing to relocate to another state is a complicated and very personal decision. If you’re thinking about retiring in a different state, read these valuable tips first.
Read more
February 21, 2023
Under the new law, beginning in 2024, you can withdraw funds from an existing 529 plan and roll them into a Roth IRA. There are some important rules.
Read more
February 16, 2023
The increased standard deductions under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act provided tax savings for many. Taxable income can be reduced further with a few strategic steps.
Read more
February 14, 2023
Retirement funds don't have to be off-limits if you're in dire need. Here're a few ways to withdraw from your 401(k) early without incurring a penalty from the IRS.
Read more
February 9, 2023
Your retirement plans don’t affect just you — they also have an impact on your children. Here’s what they need to know about your finances.
Read more
February 7, 2023
Saving for retirement takes years of planning. Retirees share their best advice on retirement, what worked for them and what didn't.
Read more
January 31, 2023
Going to all cash can make sense in some situations, but the potential downsides include among others missing the market’s best days of high returns.
Read more
An elderly woman concerned about her retirement plan
January 26, 2023
Life happens but you don’t have to let it get in the way of your retirement. Here's what you can do to protect your nest egg.
Read more
January 24, 2023
When you change jobs, you generally have four options for your 401(k) plan. One of the best options is doing a 401(k) rollover to an individual retirement account (IRA).
Read more
January 19, 2023
Inflation has been hitting everyone hard and going into 2023, there are several things you can be doing in order to protect the state of your finances.
Read more
January 17, 2023
The SECURE 2.0 Act is packed with 92 retirement-savings provisions and illustrates the importance of revisiting your retirement and tax planning strategy annually.
Read more
January 12, 2023
In a shaky economy, you may be wondering how to make smart choices when it comes to investing. This guide can help.
Read more
January 10, 2023
Contributing to a Roth IRA can be a great way to save for retirement, but putting too much money into your account can trigger tax penalties. Here're some ways to fix the problem.
Read more
January 5, 2023
Changes were made to many tax credits and deductions in 2022 that experts say could lead many people to owe money when they file their IRS returns in 2023.
Read more
January 3, 2023
It is important to reset your personal finances and goals for the New Year. Here are some financial moves that you should resolve to make in 2023.
Read more
December 29, 2022
The tax-filing system is still months away but now is a great time to start thinking about next year’s return.
Read more
December 27, 2022
Here are the critical questions about retirement plans you need to review as the close of this year approaches.
Read more
December 22, 2022
Tax season lies just around the corner, which means it’s time to seek those last-minute tax breaks. Here're a few tips.
Read more
December 20, 2022
A 529 plan allows you to save and grow tax-free money for someone’s education, including your own. Here're contribution maximums for 2023.
Read more
December 15, 2022
An inverted yield curve doesn’t always equal a recession. Even in the face of great uncertainty into 2023, there are opportunities in this inverted world.
Read more
December 13, 2022
There are many tax-planning opportunities with charitable donations that you can take advantage of to give you the largest deduction possible.
Read more
December 8, 2022
2022 has been a turbulent year for investors and retirees. However, in December, there are some actions that can have a significant positive tax and economic impact.
Read more
December 1, 2022
Many economies have been hit with rising prices in the wake of the pandemic, but there are some notable outliers that have managed to keep their inflation rate down.
Read more
November 29, 2022
Don't pay more than needed by checking out these tax-reducing steps. For more information on how you can reduce your taxes, consult your Signet advisor.
Read more
November 22, 2022
Compared to the past two seasons, this fourth quarter began with a lot of momentum, which feels like a miracle.
Read more
November 17, 2022
Is it worth the cost to hire an advisor? People say they can listen to the news to find out where and how to invest, so, “Wouldn’t I be better off just keeping the fee for myself?”
Read more
November 15, 2022
The housing market is a hot topic right now, and after experiencing rapid growth over the pandemic years it looks to now be slowing down.
Read more
November 10, 2022
Inflation remains stubbornly high. Uncertain energy costs combined with supply and demand mismatches mean higher prices could continue for a while, well beyond the end of 2022.
Read more
November 8, 2022
If you're checking, chasing, and stock-picking, you may increase the odds of self-inflicted losses when the market is down.
Read more
November 1, 2022
Despite the polarization ahead of midterms, avoid the temptation to make significant changes to a long-term investment plan based on which party controls Congress.
Read more
October 27, 2022
October is known for some of the scariest events in the financial markets. Here are 13 scary financial statistics and steps to avoid becoming their next victim.
Read more
October 25, 2022
The IRS announce the new standard deduction and new tax brackets for 2023. Knowing these numbers allows you to make some smart tax-planning moves before the year's end.
Read more
October 20, 2022
Answers to the most common required minimum distribution questions: timing withdrawals, reinvesting RMDs, and how to legally avoid paying tax on distributions.
Read more
October 18, 2022
The reasons behind the market correction are always unique, but our reactions shouldn’t be.
Read more
October 13, 2022
Although the Social Security COLA increase is the largest it’s been in four decades, it doesn’t mean that retirees are keeping up with their actual cost of living increases.
Read more
October 11, 2022
Many people aren't mentally or financially prepared for the high cost of health care in retirement. Here's how to plan.
Read more
October 4, 2022
This year is well on its way to being the worst in modern history for bond investors. But there is finally some income to be earned in the fixed-income market.
Read more
September 29, 2022
Sharp downturns in global stock markets are painful. But the odds are that jumping in and out of the market will only hurt your portfolio in the long run.
Read more
September 27, 2022
Knowing how changes in interest rates may affect the performance of your retirement plan can help you bolster your investment returns and avoid potential losses.
Read more
September 22, 2022
Near-term risks remain high, but investors who stay focused on the long-term have historically been rewarded.
Read more
September 20, 2022
If you are one of the 60 million plus individuals with an IRA, you might need to complete certain IRA transactions by the end of this year.
Read more
August 31, 2022
How you react to volatile markets plays a crucial role in your long-term success. Here are a few steps to take when the market gets scary.
Read more
August 30, 2022
Protecting your family is important, but so is making sure you're not wasting money on life insurance that could be used for other financial needs.
Read more
August 25, 2022
Here is a list of 10 common credit card mistakes cardholders make. Hopefully, you can learn from the mistakes of others and save some financial pain.
Read more
August 23, 2022
Whether you're a long-term investor trying to understand market moves or are concerned about your portfolio, here are 9 charts every investor needs to see.
Read more
August 18, 2022
Market declines during the first five years of retirement can have a significant effect on a financial portfolio, but remaining flexible can mitigate the damage.
Read more
August 16, 2022
The dramatic history of the Inflation Reduction Act is known – now we have to understand and live with the practical results.
Read more
August 11, 2022
Smart estate planning will minimize the tax bill that your heirs pay when you die, and a Roth IRA is one of the most effective tools for that purpose.
Read more