Success in investing requires patience
Stephen Tuttle

There are many successful investment strategies that have performed well over time. Yet, capturing these returns is not easy for investors. Patience can help.

Years of investment experience have taught us that all investment strategies, even ones that have outperformed over time, go through periods of underperformance. This can lead many investors to sell out of a good strategy, often at the worst time, which can destroy long-term results.

A recent study by Chris Tidmore and Andrew Hon from Vanguard Research, “Patience with active performance Cyclicality: It’s harder than you think”, concluded that investors need to endure long periods of underperformance in the hopes of achieving excess return over the long-term. The study examined the patience needed from investors by quantifying the wide range of occurrences, lengths, and degrees of return swings that occur with active management or factor-based strategies.

Key findings of the study

  • Long-term outperforming strategies are prone to large drawdowns and frequently lag their benchmark indexes, sometimes by wide margins.
  • Almost all outperforming traditional active equity managers and equity factors have frequent periods of underperformance relative to the equity market, some of which are long in duration and large in magnitude. 
  • Close to 100% of outperforming funds have experienced a drawdown relative to their style and median peer benchmarks over one-, three-, and five-year evaluation periods.
  • Eight out of 10 outperforming funds had at least one five-year period when they were in the bottom quartile relative to their peers.
  • More than half of outperforming active equity funds have underperformed their style and median peer benchmark by at least 20%—and three-quarters of funds that recovered from their largest drawdown took more than three years to do so.
  • About 70 percent of outperforming funds underperformed their style benchmarks between 40 percent and 60 percent of all one-year evaluation periods.
  • An outperforming manager can expect to experience a continuous drawdown lasting 2 years or more every 10 years and a drawdown of at least 20% over time.

Another paper by Jeffrey Ptak from Morningstar, “Winning funds often look like losers” reached similar conclusions in 2016. It studied the 20-year returns of all unique diversified US mutual funds as of October 31, 2016. It found that funds in the top 10% for the 20-year period lagged their indexes in more than one of every three rolling three-year periods. In other words, the top funds spent roughly a third of the time underperforming.

Implications for investors

  • Success in investing requires patience. You need patience when what you are invested in is performing poorly—and you need it when what you don’t own is performing well.
  • View periods of underperformance as inevitable, rather than something which triggers regret and the impulse to sell.
  • Performance track records can be misleading. It is not enough to select investment strategies based on 1-, 3-, or 5-year track records alone.
  • Randomness and chance affect returns. Sometimes good strategies do poorly, and sometimes poor strategies do well.
  • The benefits of using outperforming managers and factor tilts can be significantly eroded, if an investor fails to maintain a long-term patient perspective. Even outperforming managers experience inconsistent returns, and this wears on patience.
  • Consistency is not the goal. Markets do not provide consistent rewards even for skilled managers. The more genuinely active a strategy is, the greater the likelihood it will experience spells of pronounced and often extended underperformance. This makes it hard for many investors to reap the long-term benefits.

This is not a slight on active strategies. There are plenty of active managers and factor-based strategies that have generated attractive returns over time. Even successful active approaches will suffer periods of challenge.

For it to work, it has to be hard. If achieving outperformance with a certain strategy was “easy”, enough investors would flood the strategy with money, pushing prices higher, until it stopped working. Rather, for a strategy to outperform in the long run, it has to be hard enough to stick with I the short term that it causes investors to “bail-out” and effectively pass along the opportunity to outperform to those with the fortitude to “hold.”

Don’t chase returns. It seems sensible to buy outperforming strategies and sell the laggards. And it feels better, emotionally. This is simple performance chasing, which doesn’t often end well for investors. On the other hand, it requires a great deal of discipline to stick with a strategy that is underperforming, even when we believe that short-term results are not consistent with reasonable expectations and analysis.

Signet can help

One of the major benefits of working with a Signet advisor is behavioral coaching. We help clients make informed decisions with their wealth. We seek to manage your expectations and increase your confidence in your financial plan, thereby improving your patience with your investment choices.

To learn more about how Signet can help you create and stick with a well-designed investment plan, please contact your Signet advisor, or Steve Tuttle directly at 800-390-2755 or  

You might also like
a person filling out a car loan application form
January 20, 2022
Auto loans are reaching the longest term and highest balance ever. Should you refinance? It really depends on what you stand to gain by refinancing.
Read more
Chart: Consumer Price Index 2018–2023
January 18, 2022
Things are about to get worse — but after that, they should steadily get better. That’s roughly how economists envisage the path of U.S. inflation in the year ahead.
Read more
January 13, 2022
Inflation was last this high around 40 years ago, but prices were falling in the early ’80s as the Fed pushed the economy into a recession. What do these two periods have in common...
Read more
January 11, 2022
The SECURE Act 2.0, autoenrollment expansion, and a continuing question: just how are retirees doing, anyway?
Read more
January 6, 2022
During the early stage of our careers, it can be challenging to prioritize retirement savings. If you haven't managed it yet, you can still get starting saving later in life.
Read more
January 4, 2022
Surprise medical bills have become increasingly common and stressful. Now, thanks to the No Surprises Act, surprise medical bills may be a thing of the past.
Read more
December 30, 2021
The New Year is the perfect time to set smart financial planning goals. Here are the top ten tips for how to step forth with a good financial audit in 2022.
Read more
December 28, 2021
As political debates around tax policy continue, here’s what to do now and in the coming months to possibly get a quicker and bigger tax return in 2022.
Read more
December 23, 2021
In case paper documents are filling up your drawers, you may be wondering which documents you need to keep and what you can shred or otherwise dispose of.
Read more
December 21, 2021
Stocks are slumping amid concerns over the Omicron variant and fresh restrictions being imposed by a number of countries.
Read more
December 16, 2021
Over time, making little changes to your finances can add up. The earlier you take these steps, the longer they have to work and the greater your outcomes will be.
Read more
December 14, 2021
One factor in inflation is if people expect it to keep rising. Knowing the answer helps determine when and how much the Federal Reserve raises interest rates.
Read more
December 9, 2021
A good financial planner should be able to help you answer various Social Security questions and find the right time for you to claim Social Security benefits.
Read more
December 6, 2021
As the year comes to an end, it's important to start planning your 2021 taxes to reduce your obligations wherever possible.
Read more
November 23, 2021
While the maximum Roth IRA contribution remains $6K (with a $1K catch-up contribution for those 50 and older), the phase-out ranges for eligibility to contribute have changed.
Read more
November 1, 2021
Inflation worries grow as the economy reopens. Steve Tuttle explains how to position your portfolio for financial success regardless of how much prices rise.
Read more
October 25, 2021
Amid the market volatility fear and greed can get the best of investors. These tips help control your emotions and achieve long-term success in the markets.
Read more
September 21, 2021
Financial security in retirement takes planning, commitment, and money. These 4 questions help identify your goals and needs within a retirement strategy.
Read more
Dividends chart
July 6, 2021
Do you want to invest for retirement? Dividend-paying stocks can help preserve your capital over long term and generate income regardless of market conditions.
Read more
Impact of tax hikes on the stock market
April 28, 2021
Tax policy impacts corporate earnings and the stock market. However, over the long haul, other factors have more influence on the stock market performance.
Read more
March 23, 2021
Every correction seems like the start of a downturn. Yet market corrections don't lead to lengthy bear markets. Read how Signet handles market volatility.
Read more
March 9, 2021
Real assets can hedge against inflation in the current environment. Find out what two types of real assets Signet advisors focus on for a balanced portfolio.
Read more
February 1, 2021
The GameStop and AMC Entertainment story has dominated headlines recently. Steve Tuttle on why this won't have a big, lasting impact for long-term investors.
Read more
Investment lessons from 2020
January 14, 2021
2020 was a year of major upheaval. Here’re universal and timeless investment guidelines from Signet advisors to help you improve your financial situation.
Read more
8 ways to help lower your taxes
December 9, 2020
It’s a tough year for tax planning without knowing for sure which party will control the Senate. However here's how Signet advisors help clients save taxes.
Read more
November 1, 2020
Some investors think putting their money with multiple financial advisors means better results. This is not necessarily the case. It can make things worse.
Read more
October 8, 2020
In a joint study with Duke University’s Fuqua School of Business, Signet investigates how patent disclosure impacts stock price of the focal patent company.
Read more
October 1, 2020
President Obama and President Trump pursued different policies while in office. Yet results in the financial markets were awfully similar during their terms.
Read more
September 1, 2020
Sector investing is an underrated strategy for investors, while it complements a core portfolio by seeking to enhance returns or diversifying portfolio risks.
Read more
July 1, 2020
Careful asset placement helps save on taxes. Asset location seeks to identify the right type of investment to own in retirement plans vs. taxable accounts.
Read more
June 1, 2020
No single factor works all the time. Steve Tuttle highlights the performance of factor investing and shows why portfolio diversification is so important.
Read more
May 1, 2020
As Signet carefully monitors risks, we deem tax-exempt municipal bonds are generating tremendous interest from investors. See the analysis for our optimism.
Read more
April 1, 2020
COVID pandemic short-term dynamics are rapidly changing causing many unknowns. Signet explains what to focus on to improve financial standings post crisis.
Read more
February 26, 2020
Steve Tuttle comments on market volatility and what to do if you are worried. Hint: don’t let coronavirus fears rattle your investment plan.
Read more
January 1, 2020
The new law expands opportunities to save for retirement, but changes the way beneficiaries receive money from inherited IRAS. Steve Tuttle gives highlights.
Read more
December 1, 2019
The end of the year is viewed as a time of spending. It can also be a time to consider tax-saving strategies. Here're the Signet advisors' tips for retirees.
Read more
October 1, 2019
The media flurry around the elections received a boost from impeachment talk. How will the complexities that follow major political events impact markets?
Read more
August 1, 2019
The S&P 500 is again near all-time highs. Psychologically, it can be tough for some investors to stay invested and buy. However, it is not a signal to sell.
Read more
July 1, 2019
Investing during retirement can be a daunting task. Steve Tuttle explains how to build a sound retirement plan that will increase your chances of success.
Read more
June 4, 2019
Short-term bond strategies are attractive for investors seeking to enhance yield while defending against volatile markets. Here's more about their benefits.
Read more
April 1, 2019
Steve Tuttle discusses strategies on how to deal with higher federal tax liability from newly imposed limits on deductions for state and local taxes.
Read more
March 4, 2019
The emotional toll from the stock market crash of 2008 still lingers for retirees. To avoid a similar calamity may of them reduce exposure to equities.
Read more
February 1, 2019
Due to lower income tax rates the benefits to establishing Roth accounts are increasing. Here're strategies to optimize the use of tax-advantaged accounts.
Read more
September 24, 2018
Driven by fear of underperforming the market, investors tend to focus on stock market benchmarks. But benchmarking investment can take your eye off the ball.
Read more
July 3, 2018
Yield curve causes anxiety with some investors. Fixed income CIO, Steve Tuttle, discusses bond yields and where Signet sees income opportunities heading.
Read more
April 3, 2018
Today’s backdrop requires a fresh approach to bond investing. Here are the strategies that can reduce equity risk while providing liquidity and income.
Read more
January 3, 2018
Steve Tuttle shows why investors shouldn't bet against bonds. As stock and other risk assets rise in value, bonds are an important diversifying asset class.
Read more
December 15, 2017
Our healthcare system is complex and difficult to navigate. Signet Financial Management provides a summary of the healthcare programs available to retirees.
Read more
December 1, 2017
Even in a rising rate environment, bond ladders can mitigate downside equity risk and diversify portfolios through good and bad market cycles.
Read more